Despite being a top prospect, Jermod McCoy’s draft stock plummeted due to significant injury concerns. The cornerback from Tennessee suffered a torn ACL at the end of the 2024 college football season and did not play in 2025. Originally projected as a top-15 pick, he fell out of the first round in the 2026 NFL Draft.
At Tennessee’s pro day, McCoy ran a 40-yard dash in an impressive 4.37 seconds. This performance raised hopes among scouts that he could still be a valuable asset. However, teams remain cautious about his long-term durability because of his knee injury.
McCoy’s last game was on December 21, 2024, against Ohio State. He had standout performances during the 2024 season and earned All-American honors. Yet, concerns linger about his knee—he could require another surgery due to a bone plug issue.
Colton Hood, McCoy’s teammate, was selected by the New York Giants with the 37th pick. Meanwhile, McCoy could be picked by several teams including the Las Vegas Raiders and Cincinnati Bengals, who hold picks 41 and 42 respectively. The New Orleans Saints, New York Jets, Baltimore Ravens, and Minnesota Vikings are also potential suitors.
Adam Schefter noted that “McCoy clearly is a first-round talent but suffered a knee injury where he tore his ACL.” He added that there are questions about McCoy’s longevity in the league. Some teams worry that the bone plug used to address cartilage issues might need replacing, requiring further surgery.
McCoy was previously ranked as the top cornerback and No. 6 overall prospect on CBS Sports draft analyst Mike Renner’s big board. His dramatic fall highlights how injuries can drastically impact player valuations in professional sports.
The exact nature of McCoy’s knee issues remains unclear. Officials have not confirmed whether he will need additional surgery or what that would mean for his career moving forward.
